Matt:
My go to post workout snack usually consists of something quick and balanced.  I usually do a protein shake, with a handful of almonds and some type of berries.
Jamie

Almonds or almond/peanut butter. Occasionally I'll splurge on some high vitamin/high protein shake, like Myoplex.

Brian:

If I have some whey protein powder that is great.  It is easy to prepare and gets into my system quickly.  But if I don't have any protein I usually would have some veggies and protein (hamburger, chicken, bison, etc.).  So usually bell peppers, broccoli, protein, and mesclun mix/romaine lettuce.